top of page


Cookies purchased from The Rare Treats Baking Company can only be shipped within New York State as per home processing rules.  If an order is placed and the address is outside of New York State, your order will be returned and refunded.  

If within New York State, an additional $25 shipping charge will be added to include the USPS shipping fee as well as the shipping materials, including bubble wrap for each cookie and air pockets for the box. 


Pickup is the preferred method of getting cookies and treats to our customers!  Once an order is placed, you will be contacted directly, and the pickup address will be shared. 

Please note - Pickup is in Malverne, NY only.  

Delivery will be done on a case-by-case basis within Long Island and select boroughs of New York City.  There is an extra charge for delivery based on mileage from Malverne and all deliveries to Manhattan will incur an added charge to cover the cost of tolls. 

bottom of page